• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Philosophy Professor logo

PhilosophyProfessor.com

  • Philosophers
  • Philosophies

Act utilitarianism

Table of Contents

  • 1 Definition
  • 2 Example of Act Utilitarianism
  • 3 What is act utilitarianism?
  • 4 Rule vs Act Utilitarianism
  • 5 Related Products
    • 5.1 Moral Tribes: Emotion, Reason, and the Gap Between Us and Them
    • 5.2 Social Justice
    • 5.3 Principia Ethica (Dover Philosophical Classics)
    • 5.4 Match Point
    • 5.5 Philosophical Provocations: 55 Short Essays (The MIT Press)
    • 5.6 Supererogation (Cambridge Studies in Philosophy)
    • 5.7 The Happiness Philosophers: The Lives and Works of the Great Utilitarians
    • 5.8 Indigo Bunting: An Allegory in One Act
    • 5.9 The Devils Came in from the Country
    • 5.10 Utilitarianism and Cooperation
    • 5.11 Related:
  • 6 Videos
  • 7 Related Products
    • 7.1 Moral Tribes: Emotion, Reason, and the Gap Between Us and Them
    • 7.2 Social Justice
    • 7.3 Principia Ethica (Dover Philosophical Classics)
    • 7.4 Match Point
    • 7.5 Philosophical Provocations: 55 Short Essays (The MIT Press)
    • 7.6 Supererogation (Cambridge Studies in Philosophy)
    • 7.7 The Happiness Philosophers: The Lives and Works of the Great Utilitarians
    • 7.8 Indigo Bunting: An Allegory in One Act
    • 7.9 The Devils Came in from the Country
    • 7.10 Utilitarianism and Cooperation

Definition

Act utilitarianism is a utilitarian theory of ethics which asserts that a person’s act is morally correct if, and only if, it produces the best possible results (more happiness for more people) in that specific situation. The classical utilitarians, including Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill and Henry Sidgwick, define happiness as pleasure and absence of pain.

Also called “extreme” or direct utilitarianism.

Original, and “official” form of utilitarianism which says that our duty on any occasion is to act in the way which will produce actual overall consequences better than (or at least as good as) those that any other act open to us would produce.

Example of Act Utilitarianism

To understand how act utilitarianism works, compare the consequences of watching TV all day tomorrow with the consequences of doing charity tomorrow. One could produce more happiness in the world by doing charity work tomorrow than by watching television all day. According to act utilitarianism, then, the right thing to do tomorrow is to go out and do charitable works; it is not right to stay home and watch television all day.

What is act utilitarianism?

Act utilitarianism is based on the principle of utility, which is the basis of all utilitarian theories and is best summarized in Bentham’s well-known phrase:

“The greatest happiness for the greatest number”.

Jeremy Bentham supported his theory with another famous quote of his:

“Nature has placed mankind under two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure. It is for them alone to point out what we should do, as well as to determine what we should do”.

Bentham’s utilitarianism is a hedonistic theory and begins with the premise that people are hedonistic by nature. This means that he believed that people would actively seek pleasure and avoid pain, if given the opportunity.

Critics sometimes cite such prohibitions on leisure activities as a problem for act utilitarianism. Critics also cite more significant problems, such as the fact that utilitarianism seems to imply that specific acts of torture or slavery would be morally permissible if they produced sufficient happiness.

Difficulties in predicting consequences, including difficulties in principle where self-prediction is concerned, mean that as a practical prescription utilitarianism can only tell us to aim for the best probable outcome, and act utilitarianism has often been superseded by rule utilitarianism.

Source: J J C Smart, ‘Extreme and Restricted Utilitarianism’, Theories of Ethics, P Foot, ed. (1967); defends the former.

Rule vs Act Utilitarianism

The act utilitarianism is often contrasted with a different theory called rule utilitarianism. Rule utilitarianism asserts that morally correct action is that which is in accordance with a moral rule whose general observance would create the greatest happiness.

What is the difference between act and rule utilitarianism?

Act utilitarianism analyses the consequence of a decision as a particular act, while rule utilitarianism evaluates a consequence as if it were to be replicated later in the future. Act utilitarianism has an initial approach to examining the consequences of a current act. Rule utilitarianism differs by evaluating consequences on the basis of a specific rule followed.

It is sometimes thought that rule utilitarianism avoids the problems associated with act utilitarianism.

  • Related Products

     
    Moral Tribes: Emotion, Reason, and the Gap Between Us and Them

    Moral Tribes: Emotion, Reason, and the Gap Between Us and Them

    • Amazon Kindle Edition
    • Greene, Joshua (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 422 Pages - 10/31/2013 (Publication Date) - Penguin Books (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Social Justice

    Social Justice

    • English (Publication Language)
    • 304 Pages - 07/23/1998 (Publication Date) - Routledge (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Principia Ethica (Dover Philosophical Classics)

    Principia Ethica (Dover Philosophical Classics)

    • Amazon Kindle Edition
    • Moore, G. E. (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 196 Pages - 03/07/2012 (Publication Date) - Dover Publications (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Match Point

    Match Point

    • Condition: New
    • Format: DVD
    • Color; Dolby; DVD; Subtitled; Widescreen; NTSC
    • Scarlett Johansson, Jonathan Rhys Meyers, Emily Mortimer (Actors)
    • Woody Allen (Director) - Woody Allen (Writer) - Charles H. Joffe (Producer)
    • English, Spanish, French (Subtitles)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Philosophical Provocations: 55 Short Essays (The MIT Press)

    Philosophical Provocations: 55 Short Essays (The MIT Press)

    • Amazon Kindle Edition
    • McGinn, Colin (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 328 Pages - 08/11/2017 (Publication Date) - The MIT Press (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Supererogation (Cambridge Studies in Philosophy)

    Supererogation (Cambridge Studies in Philosophy)

    • Heyd, David (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 200 Pages - 04/30/2009 (Publication Date) - Cambridge University Press (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    The Happiness Philosophers: The Lives and Works of the Great Utilitarians

    The Happiness Philosophers: The Lives and Works of the Great Utilitarians

    • Amazon Kindle Edition
    • Schultz, Bart (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 454 Pages - 04/24/2017 (Publication Date) - Princeton University Press (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Indigo Bunting: An Allegory in One Act

    Indigo Bunting: An Allegory in One Act

    • Amazon Kindle Edition
    • Duggins, Angela (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 15 Pages - 11/27/2019 (Publication Date)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    The Devils Came in from the Country

    The Devils Came in from the Country

    • O'Neal, James Anderson (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 280 Pages - 10/01/2019 (Publication Date) - Three Ocean Press (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Utilitarianism and Cooperation

    Utilitarianism and Cooperation

    • Hardcover Book
    • Regan, Donald H. (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 296 Pages - 10/23/1980 (Publication Date) - Oxford University Press (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
  • Related:

    • Bentham’s theory of utilitarianism
    • utilitarianism
    • rule utilitarianism
    • hedonistic utilitarianism
    • preference utilitarianism

  • Videos

  • Related Products

     
    Moral Tribes: Emotion, Reason, and the Gap Between Us and Them

    Moral Tribes: Emotion, Reason, and the Gap Between Us and Them

    • Amazon Kindle Edition
    • Greene, Joshua (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 422 Pages - 10/31/2013 (Publication Date) - Penguin Books (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Social Justice

    Social Justice

    • English (Publication Language)
    • 304 Pages - 07/23/1998 (Publication Date) - Routledge (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Principia Ethica (Dover Philosophical Classics)

    Principia Ethica (Dover Philosophical Classics)

    • Amazon Kindle Edition
    • Moore, G. E. (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 196 Pages - 03/07/2012 (Publication Date) - Dover Publications (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Match Point

    Match Point

    • Condition: New
    • Format: DVD
    • Color; Dolby; DVD; Subtitled; Widescreen; NTSC
    • Scarlett Johansson, Jonathan Rhys Meyers, Emily Mortimer (Actors)
    • Woody Allen (Director) - Woody Allen (Writer) - Charles H. Joffe (Producer)
    • English, Spanish, French (Subtitles)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Philosophical Provocations: 55 Short Essays (The MIT Press)

    Philosophical Provocations: 55 Short Essays (The MIT Press)

    • Amazon Kindle Edition
    • McGinn, Colin (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 328 Pages - 08/11/2017 (Publication Date) - The MIT Press (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Supererogation (Cambridge Studies in Philosophy)

    Supererogation (Cambridge Studies in Philosophy)

    • Heyd, David (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 200 Pages - 04/30/2009 (Publication Date) - Cambridge University Press (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    The Happiness Philosophers: The Lives and Works of the Great Utilitarians

    The Happiness Philosophers: The Lives and Works of the Great Utilitarians

    • Amazon Kindle Edition
    • Schultz, Bart (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 454 Pages - 04/24/2017 (Publication Date) - Princeton University Press (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Indigo Bunting: An Allegory in One Act

    Indigo Bunting: An Allegory in One Act

    • Amazon Kindle Edition
    • Duggins, Angela (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 15 Pages - 11/27/2019 (Publication Date)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    The Devils Came in from the Country

    The Devils Came in from the Country

    • O'Neal, James Anderson (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 280 Pages - 10/01/2019 (Publication Date) - Three Ocean Press (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
     
    Utilitarianism and Cooperation

    Utilitarianism and Cooperation

    • Hardcover Book
    • Regan, Donald H. (Author)
    • English (Publication Language)
    • 296 Pages - 10/23/1980 (Publication Date) - Oxford University Press (Publisher)
    Check Price on Amazon
  • Last update 2020-06-17. Price and product availability may change.

    mereology

    holism

    truth conditional semantics

    modal realism

    fido-fido theories

    • Contact
    • Facebook

    Copyright © 2022 · CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON SERVICES LLC. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED “AS IS” AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME. “AS AN AMAZON ASSOCIATE I EARN FROM QUALIFYING PURCHASES.”